During her time in "Total Drama: Return to the Island", Tyra is placed on the Toxic Gophers. She mostly avoids interacting with the other contestants but manages to befriend Quinford and Vanessa. Tyra also establishes a relationship with Ashleigh which continues for the duration of the series. Her stretch in the competition comes to an end when she challenges Ryan and he convinces his alliance of Alex and Ethan to vote her off. Tyra is last seen in "This Ain't The End" celebrating with the other contestants after Vanessa wins the season.