During his time in "Total Drama Reloaded", Mike is placed on the Mutant Maggots and attempts to hide his dissociative identity disorder from the rest of his team. He befriends several of his peers and develops romantic feelings for Zoey which are reciprocated by her. Mike is initially the first cast member eliminated in the series before he returns later in the season. His stretch in the competition finally comes to an end when his peers vote him off a second time as a result of being overwhelmed by his alternate personalities. Mike is last seen in "Until We Meet Again" celebrating with the other contestants after Brick wins the season.