During her time in "Total Drama: Return to the Island", Laurie is placed on the Mutant Bass. She mostly avoids interacting with the other contestants but manages to start a rivalry with Schmidt. Later, Laurie also forms an alliance with Ashleigh and Vanessa to vote off Ryan. Her stretch in the competition comes to an end when she and Schmidt tie in a vote and Chris decides to eliminate them both. Laurie is last seen in "This Ain't The End" celebrating with the other contestants after Vanessa wins the season.