During his time in "Total Drama Island", Justin is placed on the Screaming Gophers and starts a rivalry with Tyler.
Finally, Justin returns to compete in "Total Drama Action" and is placed on the Screaming Actors. He is initially eliminated before returning later in the season. His stretch in the competition comes to an end when he attempts to blackmail his teammates to no avail and they vote him off instead. Justin is last seen in "Celebrity Manhunt's Total Drama Special" where he reveals he is pursuing a career in modeling.