During his time in "Total Drama: Return to the Island", Brandon is placed on the Mutant Bass before being moved to the Toxic Gophers. His team votes him off when they are unsatisfied with his performance in the sixth challenge, but Chris selects Brandon to switch teams instead. Despite this, he goes on to befriend several of his peers, particularly LaTasha and Vanessa.
Finally, Brandon debuts midseason in "Total Drama: Heroes vs. Villains" and is placed on the Heroic Hamsters. His stretch in the competition comes to an end when Samantha convinces Ethan and Trixie to vote Brandon off. At his elimination, Brandon denounces his friendship with Ethan and resolves his conflict with Ryan, his most hated rival. Brandon is last seen in "The Very Last Episode, Really This Time!" boating away from the island with Alex, Ethan, Ryan, Samantha, Trixie, and Vanessa.